contact@gertlerlawoffice.com
906 Sheppard Avenue West, Unit 4, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M3H 2T5

Follow us:

GERTLER LAW OFFICE SERVICES | JUDICIAL REVIEWChallenge a Refused Immigration Application

What Is Judicial Review?

Judicial Review is a legal process where the Federal Court examines the actions of a decision-maker, like Immigration, Refugee and Citizenship Canada (IRCC). You can challenge unreasonable or incorrect decisions made by IRCC by filing an Application for Leave and Judicial Review. That includes refusal of work permits, study permits, Express Entry applications, sponsorships, and other immigration final decisions.

For Judicial Review success, you typically need to demonstrate that the IRCC’s refusal decision is unreasonable. The Court assesses whether the immigration officer’s decision is logical, supported by analysis, and justifiable based on relevant facts and laws.

If your Judicial Review is successful, the Federal Court will overturn the decision. IRCC will then reopen your application and assign it to a different immigration officer for reconsideration. Since 1992, Robert Gertler has filed over 2,500 Judicial Reviews.

Successful Examples

RECENT GERTLER LAW JUDICIAL REVIEWS

Work Permit and Misrepresentation 
An Applicant applied for a Canadian work permit as a welder but was refused and given a five-year ban for alleged misrepresentation. Immigration officers claimed he failed to disclose past U.S. immigration issues, even though he had openly acknowledged a prior visa refusal and explained the situation in detail. The Court found the officer ignored the evidence, relied on boilerplate reasoning, and failed to justify the ban. The Judicial Review was granted, the misrepresentation finding overturned, and the application reopened.

Special Measures Work Permit
An Applicant from Hong Kong applied for a work permit under special measures but was refused and given a five-year ban for misrepresentation. The officer claimed the Applicant’s master’s degree was illegitimate, relying on body language, limited English ability, and general reports of academic misconduct rather than evidence about the degree itself. The Court found the reasoning unreasonable, stressing that it is not the officer’s role to question the validity of an accredited degree without proof. With no evidence of fraud, the misrepresentation finding was also overturned. The Judicial Review was granted, the ban removed, and the case returned for reconsideration.

Refugee Protection and State Safety
A family from Angola and Portugal sought refugee protection in Canada, citing racism in Portugal and threats from both a police officer and a political family. Their claims were refused by the Refugee Protection Division and the Refugee Appeal Division. The Court disagreed, finding the Board ignored evidence of police racism, failure to investigate fraud, and direct threats. It ruled that the assumption of state protection was speculative and unsupported. The Judicial Review was granted, the decision set aside, and the case sent back for reconsideration.

Why Robert Gertler?

EXPERTISE, EMPATHY, DIRECT ACCESS

At Gertler Law Office, Robert Gertler files and represents Applications for Leave and Judicial Review (ALJRs) at the Federal Court of Canada.

Over three decades of dedicated immigration litigation, he has successfully overturned refusals of every kind of temporary status, including work permits and Post-Graduate Work Permits (PGWPs) study permits, super visas, and visitor visas, as well as permanent residence (PR) status, including Express Entry and Provincial Nominee Programs (PNPs), as well as Humanitarian & Compassionate Grounds, and refugee and asylum claims.

Robert’s Judicial Review expertise covers the full spectrum of immigration law and all phases of the litigation process.

Integrity is the foundation of Gertler Law Office’s practice. We give clients clear and honest assessments of their immigration situation, even when that means delivering unwelcome news. If your chances of success are limited, we will let you know right away.

When you become a Gertler Law Office client, there are no middlemen, no case managers, no chatbots. You get a specialized lawyer’s knowledge and attention through every step of your immigration matter.

Contact Gertler Law

TORONTO-BASED GLOBAL REACH
906 Sheppard Avenue W, Toronto, Ontario
EMAIL
robert@gertler.ca
TELEPHONE
+1-416-231-9188
OFFICE HOURS
Mon–Fri: 9 am to 5 pm

Frequently Asked Questions

Urgent: What is the deadline for Judicial Review?

If your Canada immigration application is refused, you need to be aware of the tight deadlines to submit your application for Judicial Review. If the matter arises in Canada, you have 15 days from the day after the date of the refusal letter to file, including weekends and holidays. If you are outside of Canada, you have 60 days to file the application. Extensions are rarely granted and only in exceptional circumstances, so it is important to act quickly.

To review your eligibility and options, contact Gertler Law Office for a complimentary consultation at 416-231-9188 or email robert@gertler.ca.

How does Judicial Review work?

Judicial Review is a formal, two-stage procedure at the Federal Court of Canada.

Stage 1: The Leave Stage. This is a written, initial stage where your lawyer must convince a judge that your case has merit. It involves filing an “Application for Leave and for Judicial Review” within strict deadlines (15 days for in-Canada matters, 60 days for overseas). Your lawyer will then prepare and file a detailed legal brief and supporting documents, known as the “Applicant’s Record”. The government’s lawyers from the Department of Justice (DOJ) will respond. A judge decides whether to grant leave for a full hearing. There is no appeal if leave is denied.

Stage 2: The Hearing Stage. If leave is granted, an oral hearing is scheduled. Lawyers for both sides present their arguments to a judge, who then issues a final decision.

Gertler Law Office negotiates with the DOJ throughout the Judicial Review process. If we can reach a Settlement with the DOJ and IRCC, the Judicial Review can be discontinued, and another immigration officer can reconsider your immigration application.

Reaching a settlement can minimize legal fees, and your application may be processed more quickly.

What happens when Judicial Review is successful?

A successful Judicial Review does not mean that your application is automatically approved.

Your application will be reopened and reviewed by a different IRCC officer. You will also have the chance to submit updated information or documents. While many re-opened applications are prioritized and approved, success is not guaranteed.

You will have a fair, fresh review of your case and, as a Gertler Law Office client, all our expertise to help.

 

What are my chances of Judicial Review success?

Every Judicial Review case is different. Success can come either through a settlement (where IRCC reopens your file before a hearing) or through a court order from a judge. There are no guarantees, but at Gertler Law Office, Judicial Reviews are a core area of practice.

Robert Gertler has over 30 years of specialized experience, having handled thousands of these cases, giving clients a real advantage. Contact him directly at robert@gertler.ca.

How are settlement versus Judicial Review hearing decisions made?

Many judicial review cases settle with the Department of Justice (DOJ) before a full court hearing. The key stage is often after filing the Applicant’s Record (the written legal argument). If the case against IRCC is clearly indefensible, DOJ lawyers often recommend settlement, allowing IRCC to consent to reopening the application. At Gertler Law Office, our strategy is to prepare such strong arguments that settlement becomes the most logical outcome, saving clients the stress and time of a hearing whenever possible.

Book a free initial consultation to discuss your options by calling 416-231-9188 or emailing robert@gertler.ca.

Can I submit new evidence during Judicial Review?

Situations can change during the immigration processing, making this a key point. A Judicial Review is strictly a review of the decision based on the information the officer had at that time. New evidence is not admissible. However, we can and do use affidavits (sworn statements) and other means to introduce new facts relevant to the legal argument.

The best way to assess the original decision, the impact of your new situation, and your options going forward is to book a free initial consultation with Gertler Law Office. Call 416-231-9188, use any of our contact forms, or email Robert directly at robert@gertler.ca.

How long does Judicial Review take?

Timelines vary based on the type of application, the case, the volume of work at the Court, and other evolving factors. If a settlement is reached with the Department of Justice, it could take just three to four months. If a hearing is held, it could take around 12 to 18 months.

For rejected study permits, a fast-track pilot project option was launched in October 2024 to reduce the Judicial Review timeline to approximately five months by simplifying procedures and eliminating hearings.

For up-to-date timelines specific to your case, schedule a free initial consultation with Gertler Law Office at 416-231-9188, via any of our contact forms, or robert@gertler.ca.

IMMIGRATION APPEALS: GERTLER LAW OFFICECall us today, email us or leave a message

Book a free initial consultation

    CASE STUDIESSearch Case Studies

    AllIn the newsSettled
    https://gertler.clientwebdev.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/GL_BrandingRefresh_v1_Logo-3a.png
    906 Sheppard Avenue West, Unit 4, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M3H 2T5
    1-416-231-9188

    Follow us:

    FREE INITIAL CONSULTATIONS

    Since 1992, Gertler Law Office has been a trusted Canadian immigration law firm focused on appeals, litigation, post-application issues, and refugee cases. Our specialties include IRCC visa and permanent residence refusals (judicial review), excessive processing delays (Mandamus), and Immigration and Refugee Board (IRB) matters. 

    Located on the traditional lands of many Indigenous peoples, we work with clients, RCICs, and employers across Canada and worldwide.
    Copyright © Gertler Law Office 2026